Forward Prizes for Poetry 2016: Felix Dennis Prize for Best First Collection – Shortlist

0
818

This year’s contenders for the Felix Dennis Prize represent an exciting new generation of poets emerging beyond the bounds of well-trodden publication routes like Faber’s New Poets scheme. From Tiphanie Yanique, an award-winning American fiction writer and poet, to Harry Giles, a familiar name on the Scottish spoken word circuit, and Ron Carey, a former engineer and recent graduate of the University of South Wales’ MPhil in Writing, the prestigious shortlist (rightly) recognizes growing contributions from outside a traditionally London-centred ‘new writing’ scene.

Harry Giles’ Tonguit (Freight Poetry, 2015) is almost certainly the most formally and linguistically inventive on the list. Concrete poems like ‘Alpe d’Huez’ and ‘Piazza dei Miracoli’ sit alongside lists, haiku sequences, pantoums, and modified sonnets, all in a smattering of Scots, carefully pruned English, and textspeak. These varied experiments amplify, rather than limit, Giles’ ability to speak to the literati and the casual reader alike. Some poems (‘Visa Wedding’, ‘Tae a Cooncillor’) address the realities of austerity and public housing, while others (‘In yer haunds thare are nae deid hings’, ‘Hogmanay’) demonstrate a clear finger on the pulse of Scotland’s independence debates and the writer’s place in them. At the same time, Giles steers clear of straightforward nationalism (the broad church of this collection includes, for example, a Scots response to seven numbers from the Tao Te Ching), in favour of the ironic, self-critical stance of his opening poem, ‘Brave’: ‘A sing o a Scotland whit hinks thare’s likely some sort o God, richt?’ We sing and wonder with him.

In contrast to Giles’ daring innovations are the finely tuned poems of Ruby Robinson’s Every Little Sound (Liverpool University Press, 2016). As its title suggests, this volume pays close attention to the sonic architecture of each line and stanza, seen most clearly in poems like ‘My Mother’:

She said the cornflake cake made her day,
she said a man cannot be blamed for being
unfaithful: his heart is not in tune with his
extremities and it’s just the way his body
chemistry is. She said all sorts of things.

Deceptively conversational, Robinson’s poems pay dividends in each repeated reading with their subtle rhymes and ear for meter. As a result, these pieces do not falter on the backs of their somewhat staid titles (‘Love’, ‘Time’, ‘Romance’, ‘Tea’, ‘Boy’, etc.), but excel in their ability to return these words their full breadth and depth. Several ventures into prose and long-narrative confessional poetry punctuate the collection, but the best pieces (such as ‘Ire’ and ‘Tuning Fork’) are pared down to couplets, and are stunning precisely on account of their grace and restraint.

Disko Bay, by Nancy Campbell (Enitharmon, 2015), takes us from the rich interiors of Robinson’s world to the bleak expanses of Iceland and Greenland, where Campbell spent several months as writer-in-residence. These poems’ spare, supple lines serve as indispensable guides in the unfamiliar visual and mythic landscape, a partnership reflected in the dual Greenlandic-English titles of many poems. Some are translations of Inuit verses, included in Enitharmon’s beautiful presentation to provide a sense of the original lyrics’ aural contours. Later pieces return us to an altered England, seen through Campbell’s eyes as lost outpost and distant relative of the deep north. Her coasts are not Brighton’s sunny beaches but ‘brooding towns’ like Bexhill, where ‘the chill sand splintered our feet / and our clothes clung to us like selkie skin’. As the lines between the collection’s geographical and emotional poles begin to blur, we come across the question at the heart of ‘Ulerussivoq / The Debate’: ‘Where does the Arctic circle end?’ Campbell’s answer – another question – is tender and telling: ‘…but why / specify an ambit when the axis, / the Geographic Pole, is in constant flux?’

Similar to Disko Bay in its ability to render a familiar landscape bare and startling is Tiphanie Yanique’s Wife (Peepal Tree Press, 2015). These are hard-hitting poems about our most intimate relationships, at once beautiful and raw with Yanique’s honest handling. Early in the collection, ‘Dictionary’, a prose poem, sets the tone: ‘wife – (European origins) a married woman. As in slave in the house. As in chef, maid, nanny and prostitute. But unpaid for these services.’ The rest of the book, like the rest of this piece, challenges our ideas of what words like ‘home’ and ‘family’ mean. Complex historical and rhetorical traditions underpin each poem, taking us into Christian allusion (‘Therapy for a Messiah Complex’, ‘Altar Call’) or colonial history (‘A Slave in the House’, ‘Traditional Virgin Islands Wedding Verse’), but always with an eye to the daily tragedies of domestic relations in the present. The last section, ‘Words (Last, Fighting, True, Etc.)’, emphasizes especially how Yanique’s burnished diction ultimately lends this tough collection its shine.

Finally, Ron Carey’s debut, Distance (Revival Press, 2015) deals tenderly and directly with memories of growing up in, and coming to terms with, the tribulations of postwar Ireland. The most moving pieces, paced with the gentle regularity of loose pentameter, are brave, heartbreaking recollections – ‘A Christmas Story’, for example, captures a father’s fears through his son’s eyes:

I shut the door but I was too slow; the darkness
Was already inside. Much later, some strange man,
Who sounded like you, cried and threw dishes
On the floor, shouting, Christ is laying-off Brickies.
It was too late when you came to say goodnight.

Like Wife and Disko Bay, this book is divided into sections, and among them ‘The World Will Break Your Heart’ is the longest and most refined. Pivoting away from the personal histories of the book’s first half, this section focuses on Carey’s work, children, and community, drawing the generations close through poems like ‘My Father Built England’, ‘Fixing A Dry Stone Wall’, and ‘Fathers and Sons’. It is these haunting lines from the section’s – and the book’s – shortest poem (‘In A Doorway’), however, that best sum up this searching volume: ‘I don’t know / If I am still worth a question. If I am / Still worth passion or pity or care. / I only know I am becoming more / Human and, in my arm, an exquisite flame’.

Last year, the Prize – previously won by Kate Clanchy, Don Paterson, and Daljit Nagra, among others – went to Small Hands, a wonderfully articulate collection by Mona Arshi. Whichever volume emerges as the winner this year will be a well-deserved addition to the Prize’s distinguished history. All five poets have grasped something that needs to be said, and in their own distinctive, exquisite ways, have made us ‘more human’. This is far more than a prize could recognise.

By Theophilus Kwek

 

Visit the Forward Prizes website here